
WHY IT SOUNDS LIKE EQUIPMENT
WITH ATTITUDE!
Conventional compressors used to be called 'leveling amplifiers'.
They were designed originally to reduce the dynamic range
of all program material so that it would record properly onto
media that had limited range such as optical film and vinyl disc.
As an engineering tool the compressor had to work in as linear
a manner as possible and to be as unobtrusive as possible, so the
attack characteristic (that is the way the changes in volume take
place) had to be smooth, and the release (how the gain recovered
when the audio signal was removed) needed to be long.
While experimenting with leveling amplifiers, engineers found that
the application of compression had an effect on the perceived sound
of music. The changes were subtle but definite; and often the least
'scientific' compressors sounded best. But equipment manufacturers
over the years have been forced (by specifications) to satisfy
these 'leveling amplifier' requirements and have tried to sell
theoretical perfection as being most desirable. Engineer users
have then tried to combine their use as leveling amplifiers and
as effects units. This has been a completely wrong approach and
has only served to create bad reputations for a number of products
because, although they behave beautifully as engineering devices,
they actually sound unmusical. In short, up to now no-one has truly
understood either the engineering requirements of compression;
or compression itself.
The JOEMEEK compressor is the first device commercially available
to have been designed purely as an effects compressor. Its purpose
is to change the way the ear perceives the sound; its action changes
the clarity, balance and even rhythmic feel of music.
DYNAMICS
The human ear has a fantastic dynamic range; it hears and can
interpret sounds from as low as a pin dropping, up to being next
to a pneumatic
drill. In fact, there are mechanisms in hearing which act as
'leveling amplifiers' and allow us to be able to hear and interpret
this
extreme range.
When very loud music is heard, there are two main mechanisms
that allow us to make sense of the sounds. These are real biological
compressors; the first one is 'software' affecting the way the
brain interprets signals from the inner ear, the second is hardware'
in the way the electrochemical impulses are passed from the inner
ear.
First the 'software compressor' in the brain softens the effect
of the loud sounds. This effect is fast acting and not long lasting.
It acts over the whole frequency range and its effect is to soften
the very loud peaks of noise or sound, if the sound is removed
or stopped suddenly, then your 'ears' (actually your brain) recovers
in just a couple of seconds to full sensitivity. Because we all
live with the effect all our lives, it is rarely noticed. The
effect takes time to act (the attack time) and has a relatively
slow recovery
time; one that can easily be mimicked electronically.
MIMIC
The JOEMEEK compressor mimics this effect and instead of the
listener's ear and brain doing the compression, the Joemeek pulls
down the
sound at precisely the right moment and amount to fool the ear
into thinking that the sound is louder than it actually is.
But doesn't any compressor do that? Actually no. Although there
are many compressors on the market that can be set to the correct
time constants to mimic the effect, the actual gain reduction
is never done properly. The problem is that the human ear is
not an
engineering device, it's non-linear in all respects.
The psychoacoustic compression effect is like turning down the
volume for an instant; but once there, the relative volumes of
sound are NOT affected further.
NOT PERFECT; JUST RIGHT.
Good Engineering Practice says that a compressor should work
logarithmically; for a certain increase of volume, the output
volume should rise
proportionally less: That is, for a 2:1 compressor, an increase
of volume of 10dB at the input should produce only 5dB increase
at the output. a continuous process where the more you put in,
the more it's pushed down.
The JOEMEEK compressor just doesn't work that way. As volume
increases at the input, a point is reached where the compressor
starts to
work and the gain through the amplifier is reduced. If the input
level keeps rising, gradually the gain reduction becomes LESS
effective and the amplifier goes back to being a linear amplifier
except
with the volume turned down. And this is precisely how the human
ear behaves! So the 'ear' is fooled into thinking that the JM
compressed sound is louder than it really is; but without the
strange psychoacoustic
effect of 'deadness' that all other compressors suffer from.
COMPRESSION CURVES AND SLOPES.
We had a problem with labeling on the JOEMEEK compressor. What
could we call the ratio switch? It's not a true ratio, it's more
a 'compression amount' control. At position 1 it just allows
a little bit of gain reduction, at position 4 it's almost a limiter!
It's unscientific but with a ratio control where the actual mathematical
ratio varies with volume level and even musical content, we were
stuck with 'slope'!
ROCK CONCERTS
The second form of compression in the human ear is mostly mechanical.
It involves certain parts of the inner ear being suppressed
so that they do not respond to the large vibrations caused by
loud
noise. The effect is much slower to take effect and can take
days to recover. This is the familiar 'deadening' effect that we
all get in extreme cases when going to a rock concert.
One of its effects is to change the way that we perceive different
frequency ranges. Basically, the louder the sound, the more
we
hear of the HF and LF parts because our sensitivity to the
mid ranges is reduced.
The Joemeek compressor, because of its bending of the loudness
contours has already fooled the ear into thinking that the
sound is louder than it really is; the bonus is that the mid
ranges
seem to jump forward and the clarity improves because the mechanical
changes that the brain thinks have taken place in the inner
ear, have not happened. With conventional compressors the 'fooling'
effect is not so complete and the ear perceives something that
is not quite right. Consequently, this additional clarity is
missing
and the whole effect is one of muddy deadness. AND this is
common
in all other compressors, particularly the newer digital dynamics
tools packages; they just don't work properly!
TIME
Of course the compression curves tell only part of the story.
There are also subtleties of the time constants of attack and
release
which have enormous effect on the musicality of the sound. The
attack time produces audio 'punch' that again is a psychoacoustic
effect, different attack times mimicking different levels of
human biological compression.
Release time is even more important to maintaining illusion;
the Joemeek compressor uses a compound release circuit that reacts
quickly to short bursts of volume, and less quickly to sustained
volume, this helps to maintain the transparency of the sound.
The
values and ranges of these timings were chosen by experiment
using wide ranges of program material.
Because of these intentional effects produced by the compressor,
it makes a perfect tool for general enhancement of overall mixes
to 'brighten', 'tighten', 'clarify' and catch the attention of
the listener, a function that is never recommended for conventional
VCA compressors.
Some historic compressors from the 1950s were used creatively
by Joe Meek and other notable engineers of the past. They achieved
some of these effects and the compressor models have become venerated
for their 'sound'; the JOEMEEK compressor achieves more, and
does
it by design.